Soccer Laws Dojo

DOGSO vs SPA: Red Card or Yellow Card?

DOGSO denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity; SPA stops a promising attack that is not necessarily an obvious chance. SPA is normally a caution, but when a penalty is awarded for an offence attempting to play or challenge for the ball, no caution is given for stopping the attack.

Four factors

Distance between the offence and the goal; the general direction of play; the likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball; and the location and number of defenders and attackers. Consider all four together.

When is DOGSO a red card outside the penalty area?

A defender trips an attacker breaking towards goal with the ball under control and no defender able to intervene: direct free kick and red card for DOGSO.

When is DOGSO a yellow card in the penalty area?

A defender attempts to tackle the ball but trips an attacker with an obvious chance: penalty kick and yellow card for DOGSO.

When does a foul or handball in the penalty area result in a red card?

A defender holds or pushes the attacker, commits a deliberate handball offence, or commits an offence with no possibility of playing the ball: penalty kick and red card for DOGSO.

Serious foul play, violent conduct or another red-card offence still requires a sending-off. A deliberate handball offence that denies a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity is a sending-off, except for a goalkeeper within their own penalty area. If a penalty is awarded for a non-deliberate handball offence that denies a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, the player is cautioned.

IFAB · Law 12 · 2026/27

Related guides and practice

5 referee practice questions

Does a defender’s touch cancel offside?

Explore DOGSO decisions in Judge DB · Watch a DOGSO match incident

Practise more decisions in the app

When is handball an offence?