Referee Review
Why was this decision made?
See the key points from a referee’s perspective
Show explanation
Referee Review
Why was this decision made?
See the key points from a referee’s perspective
Show explanationHow the footage and Laws apply
The goalkeeper committed the offence outside the penalty area, and the referee read the situation accurately to identify DOGSO. This was an excellent decision. The key question is whether this offence was DOGSO. The Laws of the Game list four considerations for DOGSO. The following must be considered: ====== distance between the offence and the goal general direction of the play likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball location and number of defenders and attackers ====== As a starting point, a one-on-one with the goalkeeper is regarded as an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. For example, if the last defending player fouls an attacking player running in behind and so prevents a one-on-one with the goalkeeper, this is denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. In this incident, the footage shows that the general direction of play of the attacking player who had broken through was drifting slightly from in front of goal towards the right. However, the goalkeeper had come out beyond the penalty area to commit the offence, leaving the goal behind completely empty. An empty goal can in itself be judged an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. Weighing all of this together, the referee sent the goalkeeper off for DOGSO. It was a very reasonable decision.
Relevant Laws
Law 12 – Fouls and Misconduct (Sending-off offences)
Official references
Check the wording of the Laws
The links above lead to official IFAB and JFA resources. The application of the Laws to this incident is the author’s analysis and is not an official view of IFAB, JFA or the competition organiser.
Red or yellow card? Watch the clip and check the four DOGSO criteria.
Review distance, direction and defenders on video, then move on to a related quiz. Judge DB is free, with no ads.
Watch DOGSO clips in the appRelated Scenes
[DOGSO] A red card for stopping a counter-attack, with the referee judging whether the offence was inside or outside the penalty area | 2026/27 J1 League Matchweek 4 Gamba Osaka vs Sanfrecce Hiroshima
[DOGSO] The referee prioritises a viewing angle to judge contact from behind | 106th Emperor's Cup Round 3 Yokohama F. Marinos vs Kyoto Sangyo University