Referee Review
Why was this decision made?
See the key points from a referee’s perspective
Show explanation
Referee Review
Why was this decision made?
See the key points from a referee’s perspective
Show explanationHow the footage and Laws apply
Watching the replay, the Y.S.C.C. Yokohama goalkeeper appears to take the kick with the ball fully stationary inside the goal area. If it is accepted that the ball was correctly placed within the goal area and completely at rest, the restart was taken correctly. In that case the ball was already in play by the time the team-mate received it, and, as that team-mate then handled the ball inside the penalty area, a penalty kick is awarded for a handball offence. It is precisely because incidents like this are rare that they can be missed. Match officials, however, have to judge fairly and impartially, and must decide on the basis of what actually happened, without taking the score or the state of the match into account. The referee did not take their eyes off the restart of the goal kick and kept watching with full concentration, and this led to the correct decision; that too makes the scene a valuable example.
Relevant Laws
Law 16 - The Goal Kick / Law 12 - Fouls and Misconduct (Handling the ball) / Law 14 - The Penalty Kick
Official references
Check the wording of the Laws
The links above lead to official IFAB and JFA resources. The application of the Laws to this incident is the author’s analysis and is not an official view of IFAB, JFA or the competition organiser.
Want to test your understanding of this decision?
Build confidence with more Laws of the Game questions in the app.
Try more questions in the appRelated Scenes
[Handball / Penalty Kick] A corner-kick decision overturned by VAR intervention for a handball against a defending player's arm | 2026/27 J1 League Matchweek 4 Nagoya Grampus vs Fagiano Okayama
[Handball] A superb decision spotting an accidental handball in a crowded area | 2021 J1 League Matchweek 1 Shonan Bellmare vs Sagan Tosu